,

Procurement & Tendering Audit Program v1.0

$21.99

A risk-led Excel audit program covering the full procure-to-pay cycle, from the procurement plan to the final payment. It has 93 procedures, a 54-risk register and a ready-to-send evidence request list. A Loss Estimator values overpricing, spend that avoided competition, award premiums, duplicate payments, unapproved variations and penalties never collected.

The tender was advertised. Three quotations are on file. The committee signed. So why did the organisation pay 20% more than the lowest bid?

Procurement losses rarely look like theft. A requirement is split into fourteen small orders so it never reaches the tender threshold. The specification is copied from one supplier’s brochure. The “lowest compliant bidder” is disqualified for a missing page while the winner’s gaps are overlooked. The contract grows by 40% through variations nobody approved. A supplier’s bank account is changed on the strength of an email. The project finishes six months late and the liquidated damages clause is never applied. Every file looks complete. The money is still gone.

The Procurement & Tendering Audit Program follows every purchase from need to final payment: planning → suppliers → sourcing → evaluation and award → contracts → contract management → payment → records and reporting. It is built for internal auditors, external auditors, procurement and finance managers, audit committees, donors and consultants who need to know whether buying is fair, competitive and good value, and what it costs when it is not.

This is a risk-led program, not a checklist. Every procedure traces one golden thread: Objective → Risk → Impact → Expected Control → Procedure → Evidence → Finding. You can show management and the board exactly why each test exists and what it protects.

The program contains 93 audit procedures across 9 sections. It is supported by a 54-risk register scored on five impact dimensions, and by a Loss Estimator that puts a money value on control gaps.

Built around recognised practice

  • Structured on COSO internal control principles and the IIA’s risk-based audit approach.
  • Follows the standard stages of public and private sector procurement: planning, sourcing, evaluation, award, contract management and payment.
  • Jurisdiction-neutral: it refers to “the procurement rules that apply to the organisation” rather than any one country’s law, so it works for government departments, councils, parastatals, NGOs and companies in any country.

What the program covers

Section 1 — Governance, Policy & Procurement Framework (11 procedures) Confirms there is an approved procurement policy with clear methods and thresholds, and that the procurement committee or tender board is properly constituted. Also checks that delegated limits are set up in the system, that duties are separated, and that declarations of interest, gifts and system access are controlled.

Section 2 — Procurement Planning & Needs Assessment (10 procedures) Tests the annual procurement plan and needs justification, and confirms budget was available before money was committed. Finds orders split to stay below thresholds, checks that the right method was chosen for the total requirement, and tests whether “emergency” buying was genuine.

Section 3 — Supplier Registration & Master Data (10 procedures) Confirms suppliers were vetted before registration and checks that they exist. Matches supplier bank accounts, addresses and phone numbers to employee data to find fictitious and staff-linked suppliers. Also tests bank detail changes, duplicate and dormant suppliers, and fair use of the approved supplier list.

Section 4 — Sourcing: Quotations & Tenders (10 procedures) Reviews specifications for wording that favours one supplier, and tests advertising, invitations and the number of valid quotations. Checks for quoting suppliers linked to each other, and tests the tender box, bid opening register, clarifications to bidders and bid security.

Section 5 — Evaluation & Award (11 procedures) Tests whether evaluation committees are independent and re-performs the scoring against the published criteria. Confirms the award went to the best evaluated bidder, values any unexplained premium, and tests direct and single-source awards, approvals, publication and notification of bidders.

Section 6 — Contracts & Purchase Orders (12 procedures) Confirms contracts were signed with authority before work started and that the contract register is complete. Agrees order and invoice prices to the award, recalculates price adjustments, and tests variations, extensions and call-offs from framework agreements.

Section 7 — Contract Management & Supplier Performance (10 procedures) Tests delivery and milestone monitoring, including site visits to compare progress with what was certified. Reviews supplier performance, values liquidated damages not recovered, confirms guarantees and insurance with issuers, and tests retention and contract close-out.

Section 8 — Payments for Goods, Services & Works (10 procedures) Confirms invoices were matched to orders and receipt evidence and that services and works were certified before payment. Tests advance payments and their recovery, runs duplicate payment tests, checks payment against contract terms and reconciles supplier statements.

Section 9 — Procurement Records, Analytics & Reporting (9 procedures) Tests whether procurement files are complete and secure. Analyses spend for red flags, traces procurement reports to source data, and tests complaints handling, procurement KPIs and follow-up of past findings.

Stock replenishment, stores requisitions and receiving of stock items are covered by the Inventory & Stores Audit Program. Fuel supply and issues are covered by the Fuel Management Audit Program. Use them together for a complete supply-chain audit.

What makes it different

  • Suggested evidence on every procedure. Each procedure names the documents to request, the evidence type and the person who holds them, so you know what to ask for and whom to ask.
  • “What to look for” red flags. Practical warning signs are built into every procedure, for example: “Supplier bank account the same as an employee’s” or “Specification wording identical to the winner’s product sheet.”
  • Ready-to-send Evidence Request List. 65 documents are grouped by 9 owners, with status tracking and overdue alerts. Filter it, send it to the client, and start fieldwork with the evidence already in hand.
  • Loss Estimator. Six calculators cover Purchase Price Variance, Non-competitive Spend, Award Premium, Duplicate Payments, Unapproved Contract Variations, and Liquidated Damages Not Recovered. Two totals keep the story honest: annual leakage for losses that repeat every month, and one-off loss for award premiums, duplicates, variations and uncollected damages. A finding like “about $88,000 a year lost by buying without competition” gets attention in a way “procedures were not followed” never does.
  • 54-risk Risk Register. Each risk is scored for Financial, Operational, Safety & Environmental, Regulatory and Reputational impact. Inherent and residual ratings calculate automatically as you assess controls.
  • Executive Dashboard. Section scores, inherent and residual heat maps, the top 10 risks, findings by rating, annual leakage and one-off loss all update live, ready for your report, exit meeting or audit committee.

What’s included

  • 1 Excel workbook with 15 tabs, with no macros and no add-ins required.
  • 93 audit procedures across 9 colour-coded sections, organised under 36 audit objectives.
  • A 54-risk Risk Register with impact and likelihood scales defined.
  • Suggested evidence, evidence owner and red flags for every procedure.
  • An Evidence Request List (65 items, 9 owners) with tracking.
  • A Loss Estimator with 6 calculators, adjustable tolerances and separate recurring and one-off totals.
  • A Findings Log (Condition, Criteria, Cause, Impact, Recommendation, management action tracking).
  • An auto-scoring Dashboard with heat maps and a top 10 risk table.
  • An About tab with a section navigator, how-to-use guide and rating definitions.

Who it’s for

  • Internal audit teams in government departments, councils, parastatals, state enterprises, universities and hospitals.
  • NGOs and donor-funded projects that must show donors their procurement is fair and documented.
  • Internal audit and risk teams in mining, construction, manufacturing, telecoms, banking and retail.
  • External auditors, forensic accountants and audit firms reviewing purchasing and contract compliance.
  • Procurement managers, finance managers and audit committees who want to test their own controls before the auditors or donors arrive.

 

# Section Procedures Focus
1 Governance, Policy & Procurement Framework 11 Policy, committee, delegated limits, conflicts of interest
2 Procurement Planning & Needs Assessment 10 Procurement plan, budget, method, split orders, emergencies
3 Supplier Registration & Master Data 10 Vetting, fictitious and staff-linked suppliers, bank detail changes
4 Sourcing: Quotations & Tenders 10 Specifications, advertising, quotations, bid opening, bid security
5 Evaluation & Award 11 Evaluator independence, scoring, best evaluated bidder, direct awards
6 Contracts & Purchase Orders 12 Signing authority, contract register, prices, variations, frameworks
7 Contract Management & Supplier Performance 10 Milestones, performance, liquidated damages, guarantees, retention
8 Payments for Goods, Services & Works 10 Matching, certificates, advances, duplicates, supplier statements
9 Procurement Records, Analytics & Reporting 9 Files, spend red flags, reports, complaints, KPIs, past findings
Total 93

Reviews

There are no reviews yet.

Be the first to review “Procurement & Tendering Audit Program v1.0”

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shopping Cart
Chat With Us
Scroll to Top